CVE1281 Summary & Reader Response (Self-healing Concrete) Draft #4

In the article, “The Self-Healing Concrete That Can Fix Its Own Cracks,” Spinks (2015) stated that Hendrik Jonkers created self-healing concrete innovation to “decrease the amount of new concrete produced, lower maintenance and repair costs for city officials, building owners and home-owners” by inlaying self-activating limestone-producing bacteria into the concrete. The self-healing concrete has a longevity of up to 200 years and helps to reduce carbon emitters. However, the concrete can only repair up to 0.8mm wide of cracks and cost €30 per metre cube more than normal concrete. According to Alker, who is director of policy at the UK Green Building Council believes that it will be hard to convince the industry to adopt the new innovation. It will take unconventional consumers and developers who are willing to test their building with the new concrete to demonstrate positive results before others will support. Jonker has also been experimenting across the world where he claims that the people realized the profit because they can save from maintenance cost.

The article discussed about the possibility of the self-healing concrete winning over the construction industry by mentioning the characteristics of self-healing concrete. However, it does not presume a major change in the industry as there is insufficient information to convince the construction industry to adopt the innovation.

Firstly, this article is to define bacterial concrete, its classification and types, mechanism adopted , advantages, disadvantages and its application in the filed of construction by literature view. Dinesh stated that bacterial concrete is eco-friendly to be used and able to self heal the cracks in the structure. He provides rich in information for the study of bacteria on self-healing concrete and it is well supported by experiments results. However, he does not talk about the possibility of it winning over the construction industry by giving actual examples or statistics. Therefore, it is hard to to convince the industry to adopt with the innovation due to the limitation of applications that he mentioned in his article.

Secondly, in this article Haoliang covers the different mechanism of self healing and categorizes concrete structure according to serving condition. He highlights self-healing based on adhesive agents, bacteria, mineral admixtures and autogenours are the four categories of mechanisms. He explains the two methods in detail for both encapsulation and vascular systems techniques. He even concludes with reinforced concrete structure by serving conditions and potentially applied self-healing mechanisms. He provides rich information for its characteristics for readers better understanding of self-healing concrete but he does not talk about the possibility of it winning over the construction industry neither convince the construction industry to adopt the innovation.

Thirdly, this article is to analyse the costs for the biological self-healing in concrete and evaluates the industrial challenges it faces. Silva provides detailed information in comparison of normal concrete and self-healing concrete. He points out the problem of normal concrete and also the path of self-concrete that is undergo. He mentions that self-concrete is under study since 1970 but only attracts attention from 2001 by the article White et al. There are two key points that he highlights the contractors are not responsible for warranty after 10 years in the industry scale whereas applied concrete should have at least of 50 years of service life. He also highlights there are structures need immediate repair once cracks appear, self-healing concrete would be the better choice as it provides guaranties for instant small cracks repair, he gives example such as underground museum to support his statement. Overall, his journal provides better understanding of self-healing concrete. However, from the two tables in comparing the cost of the two concrete, he concludes that it is too expensive for the industry to accept it with a price above €15 to €20 per m3 than the normal market. Which means it is not practical for the self-healing concrete to win over the construction industry any soon.

In conclusion, despite the short-comings and high cost of self-healing concrete. The construction industry has no confident to implement it as it is under investigation stage. With the fact that it is not commonly been used in the construction industry and it is hard for them to take risk and wait for long term gain from maintenance cost. In other words, characteristics of self-healing concrete is yet to finalise, it is not ready to convince the construction industry to adopt with the innovation.

 

Reference :

Dinesh.S, Shanmugapriyan.R & Namitha Sheen.S.T (2016, December). A Review on Bacteria -Based Self-Healing Concrete. ResearchGate.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/311970887_A_Review_on_Bacteria_-Based_Self-Healing_Concrete

 

Haoliang H. (2014, nd). A Review On Self-healing In Reinforced Concrete Structures In View of Serving Conditions. Citeseerx.

http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.847.6335&rep=rep1&type=pdf

 

Silvia. F.B (2015, January). (PDF) Industrial Application of Biological Self-healing Concrete: Challenges and Economical Feasibility. Researchgate.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/270586240_Industrial_Application_of_Biological_Self-healing_Concrete_Challenges_and_Economical_Feasibility

 

Spinks, R. (2015, June 20). The self-healing concrete that can fix its own cracks. The Guardian.https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2015/jun/29/the-self-healing-concrete-that-can-fix-its-own-cracks


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Self Introduction

Dear Professor Brad, My name is Yunhuang (YH) Wu, a Year 1 civil engineering student of yours in Singapore Institute of Technology. I graduated from Singapore Polytechnic with a diploma in civil engineering with business. Civil engineering is definitely my main interest .   T his is why I c a me back to school for my second d egree as I had already pursued d egree in c onstruction m anagement  from   Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology . B efore I joined the school in September 2020 , I had   7  years of working  experience   as a assistant project engineer. I realised there  is a need to have a d egree in c ivil e ngineering in order to become a professional engineer. In addition, effective communication skill plays an important role in the work industry .   I t helps engineers to explain of their design so as to convince their superiors . Effective communication is not simply to express my thoughts but to achieve goals after communicat ...
Read more
  The Importance of communication skills for engineers “I contend that we (engineers) are undervalued because of our widespread inability to explain what we do to the general public (and why it is so important). It is one of the hardest goals to accomplish, to be able to boil down difficult concepts into a short and easily understood presentation or elevator pitch.” Marybeth Miceli, President, Miceli Infrastructure Consulting, USA (2011) Our opinion: The work that an engineer goes through is usually very complicated, it requires years of experience on the specific field to truly understand it. Which makes it very challenging for us to explain the difficult concept in engineering through words that can be easily understood by the public. Therefore, this caused the public not able to completely understand the importance and work done by engineers, which led them to neglect   the hard work that is done by engineers..
Read more

Reader Response Draft 2 (Self-Healing Concrete)

In the article, “The Self-Healing Concrete That Can Fix Its Own Cracks,” Spinks (2015) stated that Hendrik Jonkers   created self-healing concrete innovation to “decrease the amount of new concrete produced, lower maintenance and repair costs for city officials, building owners and home-owners ” by inlaying self-activating limestone-producing bacteria into the concrete. The self-healing concrete has a longevity of up to 200 years and helps to reduce carbon emitters. However, the concrete can only repair up to 0.8mm wide of cracks and cost €30 per metre cube more than normal concrete. According to Alker, who is director of policy at the UK Green Building Council believes that it will be hard to convince the industry to adopt the new innovation. It will take unconventional consumers and developers who are willing to test their building with the new concrete to demonstrate positive results before others will support. Jonker has also been experimenting across the world where he claims ...
Read more